Consignment
Fanatics Collect consignment in Santa Barbara
When you'd rather let the auction market set the price, our sister brand TrophyClub lists your cards in Fanatics Collect's weekly auctions and pays you a published percentage of the total sale.
How it works
- Send photos the same way you would for a sale. We tell you whether the card is better sold outright or consigned.
- Ship with a prepaid, insured label, or drop the cards at an appointment in Santa Barbara.
- TrophyClub lists the card in the next Fanatics Collect weekly auction under its consignor account.
- When the auction closes, you're paid your percentage of the total sale price.
Payout rates
Payout is a percentage of the total sale price, meaning the winning bid plus Fanatics' 20% buyer's premium. The bracket is set by that total, so the premium can push a card into a better tier.
| Total sale price | Your payout |
|---|---|
| Under $150 | 85% (minus a $5 handling fee) |
| $150 to $499 | 89% |
| $500 to $999 | 91% |
| $1,000 to $2,499 | 92% |
| $2,500 to $9,999 | 93% |
| $10,000 to $24,999 | 94% |
| $25,000 and up | 95% |
Rates published by TrophyClub, last updated July 12, 2026. The live calculator at trophyclub.vercel.app shows your payout for any bid.
Sell outright or consign?
Sell outright when
- You want money this week, not in three to five weeks
- The card is under about $500, where auction fees and time eat the upside
- You'd rather have a certain number than a possible one
Consign when
- The card is a true grail, $2,500 and up, where bidding wars happen
- It's rare enough that no single buyer can price it confidently
- You can wait for the auction cycle and want the highest expected number
Why not consign to Fanatics Collect directly?
You can. Fanatics Collect charges sellers a 6% fee on standard sales and, since the 2026 National, waives the seller fee entirely if you take payment in FanCash instead of cash (Yahoo Sports). Consigning through TrophyClub means we handle photography, grading questions, shipping, listing and follow-up, and you're paid in real money, not store credit. For high-end cards the published TrophyClub tiers are competitive with going direct once you count the work.